HVAC Commissioning: The Measurements and Tolerances That Prove an Install

A system that starts and blows cold air has not been commissioned. Commissioning is measuring the handful of things that decide capacity, efficiency and equipment life, comparing them with the design and the manufacturer's data, and writing the numbers down.

This guide follows ENERGY STAR's National HVAC Commissioning Checklist and ENERGY STAR's summaries of ACCA Standard 5 (HVAC Quality Installation Specification). The manufacturer's installation instructions always come first for the unit in front of you.

What a quality install comes down to

ENERGY STAR's quality installation guide lists proper equipment sizing and component matching, correct refrigerant charge, and enough airflow to match the refrigerant capacity among its main components, and its savings table adds duct sealing. Its estimate of the savings from getting each right: refrigerant charge 2-6%, airflow 2-5%, sizing 3-7%, and duct sealing 11-18%.

1. Airflow

Check airflow first: charge readings aren't reliable until airflow is right.

  • Target: measured fan airflow within ±15% of design, and within the range in the manufacturer's product data.
  • Measure it, don't calculate it. ENERGY STAR's accepted methods: pressure matching, a flow grid, a traverse with a manometer and probe or an anemometer, the manufacturer's CFM-versus-static-pressure table, or temperature rise (furnaces only).
  • Static pressure: drill and mark test holes, measure total external static pressure, and compare it with the design value. ENERGY STAR's quality installation program allowed no more than 25% or 0.10 in. w.c. (whichever is greater) over the design static, and always within the manufacturer's range.

The usual field method is static pressure plus the blower table: read total external static, find the fan speed setting, and read CFM from the manufacturer's chart. See residential duct design basics if static is over the rating.

2. Refrigerant charge

  • Run the system 15 minutes before taking readings.
  • TXV systems: use subcooling. Liquid saturation temperature minus liquid line temperature should be within ±3°F of the manufacturer's subcooling target.
  • Fixed orifice (piston) systems: use superheat. Suction line temperature minus evaporator saturation temperature should be within ±5°F of the manufacturer's target for the indoor and outdoor conditions.
  • Cold weather: if it's below 55°F at the condenser (or below the manufacturer's minimum for cooling), the checklist doesn't use these tests. It requires the system to have a TXV, has you record the outdoor temperature, and marks the charge section N/A. Follow the manufacturer's cold-weather charging instructions.
  • Manufacturer method wins. Where the manufacturer defines its own test procedure, use it and attach it.

Record all of it: outdoor and return air temperatures, liquid and suction pressures, both line temperatures, the target and the difference. See superheat vs. subcooling and the superheat and subcooling calculator.

Before charge can be right, the line set has to be clean, tight and dry: nitrogen purge while brazing, a pressure test, and a deep vacuum.

3. Electrical

ACCA 5's installation elements include voltage, amperage and grounding. Measure supply voltage at the unit with it running and compare amp draws with the nameplate.

4. Gas furnaces: input and temperature rise

ACCA 5's fuel-fired checks, as ENERGY STAR summarizes them:

  • Firing rate (on-rate): within 5% of nameplate input. Clock the meter or measure manifold pressure per the manufacturer; see furnace gas pressure check.
  • Temperature rise: within the range on the rating plate; see furnace temperature rise.
  • Venting: per code and the installation instructions.
  • Combustion analysis where the manufacturer calls for it.

5. Ducts and room airflow

  • Duct leakage (ACCA 5, per ENERGY STAR's summary): new ducts inside conditioned space, 10% total leakage or less; ducts outside the thermal envelope, 6% or less. For existing ducts, 20% or less, or a 50% reduction from where they started.
  • Room-by-room balance (recommended on the ENERGY STAR checklist, not required): each room's measured airflow within the greater of ±20% or 25 CFM of design.

6. Controls and paperwork

  • Check that the thermostat and controls are set up per the manufacturer: staging, heat pump settings, blower speeds, and auxiliary heat lockouts where used.
  • Leave the numbers with the job. A commissioning record is what protects you on a callback, and it's the baseline for every later service call.

Printable forms: AC start-up and commissioning checklist, static pressure and airflow test sheet, combustion analysis log and the install job completion checklist.

Quick reference

Check Pass mark Source
Fan airflow ±15% of design ENERGY STAR checklist item 3.8
Subcooling (TXV) ±3°F of manufacturer target ENERGY STAR checklist item 2.15
Superheat (fixed orifice) ±5°F of manufacturer target ENERGY STAR checklist item 2.15
Run time before charge readings 15 minutes ENERGY STAR checklist section 2
Furnace firing rate Within 5% of nameplate ACCA 5, per ENERGY STAR
Room airflow (if balanced) Greater of ±20% or 25 CFM ENERGY STAR checklist item 4.2
Duct leakage, new 10% or less inside, 6% or less outside the envelope ACCA 5, per ENERGY STAR

Sources

  • ENERGY STAR, National HVAC Commissioning Checklist, Single-Family New Homes (Rev. 14): energystar.gov
  • ENERGY STAR, HVAC Quality Installation Sponsor Guide, Version 3: energystar.gov
  • ENERGY STAR / ACCA, Intro to ACCA's QA Contractor Program (summary of ACCA 5 QI elements): energystar.gov
  • ACCA, Standard 5: HVAC Quality Installation Specification (ANSI/ACCA 5 QI), the standard these documents apply.

Tools for this job

Related guides

Field reference for trained technicians. Always follow the equipment manufacturer's instructions, local code and safe work practices. See our editorial standards, or report a correction.