Walk-In Cooler and Freezer Troubleshooting: Defrost, Superheat and Iced Coils

A walk-in cooler or freezer is a remote condensing unit, an evaporator (the "unit cooler") hung inside the box, a thermostat, a liquid line solenoid and, on freezers, a defrost timer and heaters. The parts are familiar to anyone who works on air conditioning. The control sequence and the defrost cycle are what's different.

This guide follows Heatcraft's installation and operation manuals for unit coolers and condensing units. Heatcraft builds the Bohn, Larkin, Climate Control and Chandler brands. Other makes work the same way with their own numbers.

How a pumpdown system runs

Most walk-ins don't switch the compressor from the thermostat. The thermostat switches a solenoid valve, and a pressure control runs the compressor:

  1. The box thermostat closes on a rise in temperature.
  2. The liquid line solenoid opens and refrigerant feeds the unit cooler.
  3. Suction pressure rises above the low pressure control's cut-in. The control closes, and the compressor and condenser fan start.
  4. The box comes down to temperature. The thermostat opens and the solenoid closes.
  5. The compressor keeps running and pumps the low side down. When suction pressure falls to the control's cut-out, the compressor and condenser fan stop.

The unit cooler fans run the whole time. Heatcraft's standard pumpdown pressure switch is preset to cut in at 15 psig and cut out at 5 psig, and the manual says that suits most pumpdown systems.

This matters when you diagnose: a compressor that won't start may be waiting on a solenoid that never opened. Heatcraft's system troubleshooting chart lists a failed solenoid among the causes of a compressor that won't run.

How electric defrost runs

Heatcraft's unit coolers come in air, electric and hot gas defrost versions. Freezers need heat to clear the coil. On a timer-controlled electric defrost system:

  1. The timer starts defrost at set times. Heatcraft's typical setting is two to four defrosts per day for freezers, more for heavy frost loads.
  2. The timer drops out the thermostat, solenoid and evaporator fans. The compressor pumps down and stops, and the defrost heaters come on.
  3. The heaters bring the coil up through 32°F and the frost melts.
  4. When the coil reaches 45 to 55°F, the defrost termination thermostat ends the defrost and returns the timer to refrigeration.
  5. If the termination thermostat doesn't act, the timer's fail-safe ends the defrost on time.
  6. The compressor restarts. The fans stay off until the coil is cold again: the fan delay closes at a coil temperature of 23 to 30°F.

Setting the fail-safe. Heatcraft's rule is the length of the defrost plus 25%. A 20-minute defrost gets a 25-minute fail-safe.

The combined fan delay and termination control. On many Heatcraft unit coolers this is one non-adjustable switch. Its defrost termination contacts close above 55°F, and its fan contacts close below 35°F. Two things follow:

  • On the first pull-down of a warm box, the fans won't start until the coil gets down to about 35°F. If the box is still warm, the fan can blow enough warm air over the coil to open the switch again, so the fans may cycle on and off for a while. That's normal during pull-down. The manual has you wire electric and hot gas defrost fans for continuous operation temporarily until the room temperature stabilizes.
  • When testing the fan side of the control for a closed circuit, the control has to be below 35°F.

Superheat

Two superheat readings matter on a walk-in, and they're taken in different places.

At the evaporator. Check it after the box is at or near its set temperature.

  1. Measure suction line temperature where the expansion valve bulb is clamped.
  2. Read suction pressure at the access port on the evaporator's suction header.
  3. Convert that pressure to saturation temperature.
  4. Subtract. The difference is evaporator superheat.

Heatcraft's targets: 6 to 10°F for a system designed around a 10°F TD (the difference between box temperature and evaporating temperature), and 12 to 15°F as needed on higher-TD systems. A valve set for high superheat costs capacity. Low superheat risks liquid slugging and washed-out compressor bearings. The bulb has to be in solid contact with the suction line and insulated.

At the compressor. Read suction pressure at the compressor's suction service valve, and measure line temperature about a foot back from the compressor. Heatcraft recommends 20 to 30°F at a semi-hermetic compressor.

  • Too low, and liquid returns to the compressor. It dilutes the oil and eventually takes out bearings and rings, or valves.
  • Too high, and discharge temperature climbs until the oil breaks down, wearing rings, pistons and cylinder walls. Capacity also falls as suction superheat rises.

Corrections are made at the evaporator's expansion valve. On a short line run, the manual notes that the 20°F minimum at the compressor can override the evaporator targets.

Blends with glide. R-448A, R-449A and the R-407 blends have a glide of roughly 6 to 10°F, where R-404A's is about 1°F and can be ignored. Use the dew point column of the pressure-temperature chart for superheat.

Sight glass charging needs head pressure. Unless the condensing unit has flooded head pressure control, Heatcraft wants discharge pressure above the equivalent of 105°F condensing before you judge the charge or set superheat. In cold weather that can mean temporarily blocking part of the condenser face.

Troubleshooting by symptom

These follow Heatcraft's evaporator troubleshooting chart.

Box temperature too high

  • Thermostat set too high.
  • Superheat too high: adjust the expansion valve.
  • Low on refrigerant: find the leak before adding any.
  • Coil iced up: defrost it manually, then find out why the defrost controls didn't clear it.
  • Unit cooler too close to the door: relocate it or add a strip curtain.
  • Heavy air infiltration: seal the openings.

Coil not clearing during defrost

  • The coil isn't getting above freezing in defrost: check the heaters.
  • Too few defrosts per day: add cycles.
  • Defrost too short: lengthen it at the termination thermostat or the timer.
  • Bad timer or defrost thermostat.

To test a heater, the manual has you disconnect it and check whether it's burned out, with correct voltage across it or a continuity tester.

Ice on the ceiling around the evaporator, or on the fan guards and blades

This is the opposite problem: too much defrost, or fans starting too early.

  • Defrost running too long: adjust the termination thermostat.
  • Fan delay not holding the fans off after defrost.
  • Bad defrost thermostat or timer.
  • Too many defrosts per day.

Ice building up in the drain pan

  • Drain pan heater failed.
  • Unit not pitched correctly.
  • Drain line plugged or frozen.
  • Drain line heater failed.
  • Bad timer or thermostat.

Uneven frost on the coil

  • A failed heater.
  • Evaporator too close to a door or opening.
  • Defrost termination set too low.
  • Wrong or missing distributor nozzle.

Fans won't run

  • Power: main switch open or fuses blown.
  • Motor failed. Before condemning it, take the motor leads off the terminal block and apply correct voltage directly. Spin the blade by hand first to check it turns freely.
  • Unit is in defrost, or the coil hasn't cooled enough to close the fan delay.
  • Bad timer or defrost thermostat.

Drain lines

Heatcraft's rules for condensate drains:

  • Copper or steel, pitched at least 1/4 inch per foot, and at least as large as the evaporator's drain connection.
  • Every drain line trapped, and run to an open drain, never tied directly into the sewer. Trap each evaporator's line before any tee.
  • The trap goes in a warm space. On low-temperature units it must be outside the refrigerated box.
  • Traps outdoors and long outdoor runs get a drain line heater and at least 3/8 inch of pipe insulation. The heater is wired to run continuously.
  • Heat: 20 watts per foot for a 0°F room, 30 watts per foot for a -20°F room. In a freezer, heat and insulate the drain pan fitting too.

If the pan has ice in it, the manual's first suspect is a frozen drain line. Pitch the line sharply and get it out of the box by the shortest route.

Where the evaporator sits

Some problems are designed in. Heatcraft's placement rules:

  • The air pattern has to cover the whole room.
  • Never mount an evaporator directly above a door or door opening.
  • Leave a space equal to the unit's height between the bottom of the unit and the product, and don't stack product in front of the fans.

A unit cooler by the door shows up in the chart twice, under high box temperature and under uneven frosting.

Start-up and operating checks

From Heatcraft's condensing unit manual:

  • Energize the crankcase heater for 24 hours before start-up.
  • Voltage at the compressor terminals within 10% of the nameplate, and a balanced load on each leg of a three-phase compressor. The three-phase imbalance calculator does the math.
  • Oil level in the compressor sight glass.
  • High pressure control: the maximum approved setting on Heatcraft's air-cooled condensing units is 425 psig. Test the cut-out by disconnecting the condenser fans or blocking the condenser inlet air while watching the gauge.
  • Defrost start, termination and length, and the fail-safe.
  • Drain pan draining freely.
  • Run the system at least two hours, leave it overnight on automatic, then recheck everything.

Heatcraft also warns that adjustable controls and valves, including low and high pressure controls, adjustable head pressure systems and expansion valves, have to be set in the field for the job.

For the condensing unit side, including the maintenance schedule and cold-weather head pressure problems, see walk-in condensing unit maintenance and cold-weather problems. For cubers in the same kitchen, see commercial ice machine troubleshooting. For self-contained reach-ins, see reach-in cooler and freezer troubleshooting. For larger systems that defrost with discharge gas instead of heaters, see hot gas defrost systems.

Quick reference

Item Value Source
Evaporator superheat, 10°F TD system 6-10°F Heatcraft H-IM-UC
Evaporator superheat, higher TD 12-15°F as required Heatcraft H-IM-UC
Compressor superheat (semi-hermetic) 20-30°F, one foot from the compressor Heatcraft H-IM-CU
Defrosts per day, freezer 2 to 4 typical Heatcraft H-IM-CU
Defrost termination Coil at 45-55°F Heatcraft H-IM-CU
Fan delay after defrost Coil at 23-30°F Heatcraft H-IM-CU
Fail-safe Defrost length + 25% Heatcraft H-IM-UC and H-IM-CU
Drain line pitch 1/4 in. per foot minimum Heatcraft H-IM-UC
Drain line heat 20 W/ft at 0°F, 30 W/ft at -20°F Heatcraft H-IM-UC
Pumpdown pressure switch preset 15 psig cut-in, 5 psig cut-out Heatcraft H-IM-CU
Supply voltage Within 10% of nameplate Heatcraft H-IM-CU
Minimum condensing for charging without flooded head pressure control 105°F equivalent Heatcraft H-IM-UC

Sources

  • Heatcraft Refrigeration Products, Unit Coolers Installation and Operations Manual, H-IM-UC (May 2023), pages 3-6 and Table 8: heatcraftrpd.com
  • Heatcraft Refrigeration Products, Condensing Units Installation and Operations Manual, H-IM-CU, pages 29-31: heatcraftrpd.com

Tools for this job

Related guides

Field reference for trained technicians. Always follow the equipment manufacturer's instructions, local code and safe work practices. See our editorial standards, or report a correction.