Boiler Pressure Too High or Relief Valve Dripping: Expansion Tank and Fill Valve Checks
The relief valve is the last line of defense on a boiler. When it drips, it's usually doing its job: pressure reached its setting. The question is why the pressure got that high.
Safety: Never plug, cap or tie off a relief valve, and never set a fill valve to keep a boiler just under relief pressure. Boilers hold hot water under pressure; let the system cool and relieve pressure before opening anything. This is work for a trained technician.
How the pressure is supposed to behave
Water expands as it heats. In a closed hot-water system that expansion goes into the expansion tank, which has an air cushion on one side of a diaphragm or bladder. Cold, the gauge sits near the fill pressure. Hot, it rises a few psi and stays well under the relief setting.
Amtrol sizes its residential EXTROL tanks on a 12 psig fill pressure and a 30 psig relief valve. Your system's numbers are on the boiler's rating plate, the relief valve tag and the fill valve, so go by those.
Step 1: Watch the gauge through a cycle
- Cold reading at fill pressure, then a big climb when hot, then the valve weeps: expansion problem. Go to step 2.
- Pressure creeps up even when the boiler is off or cool: water is getting in from the supply. Go to step 3.
- Pressure is normal and the valve still drips: the relief valve seat is likely fouled or worn. Go to step 4.
Step 2: Check the expansion tank
A tank with no air charge acts like a section of pipe.
- Quick check: with the system hot, tap the tank. A tank that rings hollow on top and sounds solid lower down is normal on many models; one that sounds full of water all the way up is suspect. This is only a hint.
- Real check: Amtrol's instructions say to check precharge while the tank is isolated and empty of water. Close the valve to the tank (or isolate and drain the system near it), drain the water out of the tank, then read the air valve with an accurate tire gauge.
- Compare to fill pressure. Amtrol says to set the precharge to match the system fill pressure; its tanks ship at 12 psig. Charge with oil-free compressed air or nitrogen if it's low.
- Water out of the air valve when you press the core means the diaphragm or bladder has failed. Replace the tank.
Amtrol also notes that checking precharge lets a little air escape each time, so don't check it more often than needed.
Step 3: Check the fill valve
A pressure-reducing (fill) valve that leaks through lets supply pressure push into the boiler.
- Note the cold pressure.
- Close the shutoff valve ahead of the fill valve.
- Watch the gauge over the next several cycles. If the creeping stops, the fill valve is passing water and needs a rebuild or replacement.
Also check anything else that ties the boiler to domestic water, such as a leaking indirect water heater coil or tankless coil, which can push domestic pressure into the boiler loop.
Step 4: The relief valve itself
After the pressure problem is fixed, a valve that has lifted many times may not reseat. Replace it with one of the same pressure setting and BTU capacity listed on the original's tag. Pipe the discharge where your local code requires.
Common mistakes
- Replacing the relief valve first. The new one drips too.
- Checking tank precharge with the tank full of water. The gauge reads system pressure, not the air charge.
- Turning the fill valve down to stop the dripping without finding why the pressure climbs.
- Using a gauge that's been wrong for years. Confirm the boiler gauge with a test gauge on a drain.
FAQ
What pressure should a residential boiler be at?
Go by the system's own fill pressure and relief setting. Amtrol's residential tank sizing assumes a 12 psig fill and a 30 psig relief valve, which is common, but taller buildings need more fill pressure.
Can I add air to the expansion tank without draining it?
Not accurately. With water in the tank, the gauge reads system pressure. Amtrol's procedure is to isolate the tank and drain its water first.
Why does the relief valve only drip when the boiler is hot?
That points to expansion: the tank can't absorb the extra volume, so pressure climbs as the water heats.
Sources
- Amtrol EXTROL hydronic expansion tanks, installation and operation instructions
- Amtrol EXTROL with InSight cap, installation and operation instructions
- Amtrol Fill-Trol installation and operation instructions
HVAC Cheat Sheet is published by 90 Leads, a marketing company that works with home service businesses, including HVAC contractors.
Was this guide useful?
One field tip a week
A short, practical HVAC tip in your inbox every week: diagnostics, charging, airflow and code changes. Free, unsubscribe anytime.
We'll only use your email for the newsletter. Privacy policy.
Related guides
Air in a Hot-Water Heating System: Purging, Air Separators and Vents
Why air causes no-heat zones, noise and pump problems in a hot-water heating system, how to purge bulk air with forced-water purging (and the flow you need), and where the air separator, expansion tank and vents belong. Based on Taco's technical documents.
Boiler Short Cycling: Settings, Flow, Venting or an Oversized Boiler?
A checklist for a hot-water boiler that fires, shuts off and fires again every few minutes, based on IBC's cycling troubleshooting table for its condensing boilers. Covers control settings and differential, low water flow, air, venting and condensate, and boiler size.
Hot-Water Zone Valve Troubleshooting: Valve, Motor or End Switch?
How to find out why a hydronic zone gets no heat or won't shut off. Covers how a zone valve and its end switch start the boiler, what to measure, and how to tell a bad motor head from a stuck valve.
Boiler Circulator Not Running: Power, Relay, Seized Cartridge or Air Lock?
How to tell why a hydronic circulator pump isn't moving water - no power from the relay, a seized cartridge, or air in the pump - using Taco's own instructions for "00" circulators.
Field reference for trained technicians. Always follow the equipment manufacturer's instructions, local code and safe work practices. See our editorial standards, or report a correction.